When I bought the parts for my newest computer it was with the intend of installing Vista on it, when it arrived and setting it up as a HTPC, controlling my digital home and multimedia hub of my house… After seeing the few improvements Vista has to offer, which can be summed up to be a bit of eye-candy, a bit of security that makes daily operations far more complicated and a few new bits here and there, and then hearing of the problems it brought in terms of activation I started looking for an alternative!
I have been using Linux for a long time on my laptop, since the day of Red Hat 5.1 up till now Kubuntu 6.10, but is it a viable alternative, when Windows XP can no longer deliver what I need in my primary operating system?
One of the main problems with Linux has always been hardware-support and software-support! Let’s have a look at that!
Hardware support have moved a long way on Linux, as this article on PC World also states! There is no way around this… However, to run Linux it is always a good idea to check out the Internet for what support one can expect on Linux for the hardware that resides in your computer! Some Linux distributions even aim at persons coming from Windows!
Performance-wise Linux is pretty on par with Windows. The Linux Kernel is in most ways faster than the Windows Kernel, but better driver support, yielding faster drivers for Windows, evens up the fight.
Eye-candy wise Vista was suppose to be the Mac OS X of Windows. However, that’s not saying a lot as Linux has for a long time had a stunning visual desktop environment with KDE (or alternatively Enlightenment), coupled with Beryl for Visual Desktop Enhancement Vista is already years behind!
Ease of use is always discussed, and it is a terrible subjective issue… However, the latest version of Kubuntu (The KDE version of Ubuntu) is in my opinion as easy to use as Windows – making things in security issues far easier than Vista!
The main problem with Linux is still software support! It doesn’t matter you have a free, working, adorable, open sourced operating system with a gorgeous, effective, smart desktop environment if you can’t use or find suitable alternatives to the programs you need in your daily work! There are many great applications for Linux, some of these free alternatives are far better than their proprietary on Windows, but some things are still missing greatly! A real implementation of DirectX on Linux, the real alternative to PhotoShop (NO, Gimp is not an alternative), Real Gaming support, A more mature OpenOffice.org and not least all the legacy programs one still use on Windows, which one has paid many good money for back in its day! DirectX10 will be the big problem, as it will only be available on Vista, and it is perhaps the greatest feature of Vista!
I find it troubling that in the Open Source world are so many projects trying to develop the same thing! Why do people not coordinate better and instead reach a far better quality in their products? Linux really needs the software support – WINE isn’t always the way to go!
If Microsoft doesn’t clean up its act in terms of a proper license for Windows Vista (instead of removing all user rights), a more fair price and a realistic piracy-plan instead of this madness activation the choice for me is clear! It is Hasta-La-Vista for Microsoft’s newest attempt at an operating system and that means that I will stay on Windows XP, while keeping my sights on Linux as the alternative – switching when XP no longer delivers!